Smart Cities: models, tools, rankings, and standards

Vladimir Drozhzhinov, Vasily Kupriyanovsky, Dmitry Namiot, Sergey Sinyagov, Andrei Kharitonov

Abstract


In this paper, we discuss the models, tools, and rankings in the domain of smart cities. We describe models, which served as the basis for standardization of Smart Cities. The familiarity with these questions lets users evaluate and understand the origins and status of standardization in the field of Smart Cities. This standardization covers various aspects of design, organization, and operation of the smart city. The paper shows the role of the Internet of Things platform in smart cities and outlines different approaches to the implementation of its own platform of Smart Cities. The paper compares the proposed international standards with approaches prevailing at the present time in domestic practice. As a result, the article concludes with a presentation of standards relating to information and communication technologies smart city. In the future, the authors suggest more research on other layers of the standardization of smart cities (digital economy, urban operating system, energy, travel standards for pedestrians and cyclists, the environment and others).

Full Text:

PDF (Russian)

References


Sajt Fonda OON po narodonaseleniju (United Nations Population Fund, UNPF), razdel po urbanizacii -- http://www.unfpa.org/urbanization (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Jung-Hoon Lee. Towards a Framework for Smart Cities: A Comparison of Seoul, San Francisco and Amsterdam".. –In: INNOVATIONS FOR SMART GREEN CITIES: WHAT'S WORKING, WHAT'S NOT, WHAT'S NEXT. Oberndorf Event Center; Knight Management Center, Graduate School of Business. Stanford University, June 26-27,2012. - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rRBmwP7TBu8&feature=youtu.be (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.).

Interaktivnye karty proektov umnyh gorodov: http://www.firstpost.com/business/infographic-heres-an-interactive-map-showing-the-98-cities-selected-for-smart-city-project-2412476.html , http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/interactive-map-of-cities-chosen-by-centre-for-smart-cities-mission-1211573b , http://www.eurocities.eu/eurocities/news/EUROCITIES-smart-cities-Interactive-smart-mobility-terminal-Burgas-WSPO-AARJXH (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Robert E. Hall. The Vision of A Smart City. -- 2nd International Life Extension Technology Workshop, Paris, France, September 28,2000 -- https://www.osti.gov/scitech/servlets/purl/773961/ (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017g.)

Caragliu, A; Del Bo, C.; Nijkamp, P. Smart cities in Europe./ Serie Research Memoranda 0048. -- VU University Amsterdam, Faculty of Economics, Business Administration and Econometrics, 2009. -- http://degree.ubvu.vu.nl/repec/vua/wpaper/pdf/20090048.pdf (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Rudolf Giffinger, Haindlmaier Gudrun. Smart cities ranking: An effective instrument for the positioning of the cities. -- In: ACE: Architecture, City and Environment = Arquitectura, Ciudad y Entorno [en línea]. 2010, Año IV, núm. 12 Febrero. P. 7-25, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228915976_Smart_cities_ranking_An_effective_instrument_for_the_positioning_of_the_cities (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Stranica strategii umnogo goroda Barselona (Case Study: Barcelona's Smart City Strategy), September 19, 2014, http://www.c40.org/case_studies/barcelona-s-smart-city-strategy (Obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Sajt proekta umnogo Amsterdama (Amsterdam Smart City site), https://amsterdamsmartcity.com/ (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Which Vendors Have Gotten Smart (Computing, That Is)?, posted by Andrew Bartels on January 7, 2011, Forrester site, http://blogs.forrester.com/andrew_bartels/11-01-07-which_vendors_have_gotten_smart_computing_that_is (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Alfonso Velosa, Bettina Tratz-Ryan, Luis Anavitarte, Hiranya Fernando. Market Trends: Smart Cities Are the New Revenue Frontier for Technology Providers, 2011. – Gartner, 01 April 2011, ID: G00210890, https://www.gartner.com/doc/1615214/market-trends-smart-cities-new (Obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Rafael Achaerandio et.al. Smart Cities Analysis in Spain. – IDC White Paper, September 2011, http://www.slideshare.net/cibbva/idcwp38-t-print (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Jeanette Whyte. Smart City Project Methodology. – Genesisi Consulting, Smart City Project Methodology, EU-China Policy Dialogues Support Facility II, 30 May 2013, http://eu-chinasmartcities.eu/sites/default/files/Smart%20City%20Project%20Methodology_Jeanette%20Whyte.pdf (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Hafedh Chourabi, et.al. Understanding Smart Cities: An Integrative Framework. – In: 2012 45th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, p.p. 2290-2297, http://www.ctg.albany.edu/publications/journals/hicss_2012_smartcities/hicss_2012_smartcities.pdf (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Onlajnovyj biznes-slovar': http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/framework.html#ixzz2V5EnY2DZ (obrashhenie 10 fevralja 2017 g.)

Sajt IBM «Umnye goroda – novye kognitivnye podhody k zatjanuvshimsja problemam» http://www.ibm.com/smarterplanet/us/en/smarter_cities/overview/index.html (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

A vision of smarter cities How cities can lead the way into a prosperous and sustainable future. -- IBM Global Business Services, IBM Institute for Business Value, 2009, http://www-03.ibm.com/press/attachments/IBV_Smarter_Cities_-_Final.pdf (obrashhenie 11 fevralja 2017 g.)

Sajt Evropejskoj jekonomicheskoj komissii OON (The United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, UNECE), stranica Iniciativy po ob"edineniju za umnye ustojchivye goroda (the United for Smart Sustainable Cities Initiative (U4SSC) , http://www.unece.org/info/media/news/housingand-land-management/2016/one-un-approach-to-smart-sustainable-urban-development-the-united-for-smart-sustainable-cities-initiative/doc.html (obrashhenie 11 fevralja 2017 g.)

Stat'ja «sociotehnicheskaja sistema» v anglojazychnoj vikipedii, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociotechnical_system (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

Stat'ja «sociotehnicheskaja sistema» v vikipedii, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociotechnical_system (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

Stat'ja «IT-arhitektor» v vebopedii http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/I/information_technology_IT_architect.html (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

Stat'ja «Arhitektor» v vikipedii http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arhitektor (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

The Urban Technologist: People. Place. Technology, SEPTEMBER 26, 2012, http://theurbantechnologist.com/2012/09/26/the-new-architecture-of-smart-cities/?blogsub=confirming#subscribe-blog (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

Bystrova T. Ju. ARHITEKTURA VNE VREMENI: IDEJa ShABLONOV PROEKTIROVANIJa K. ALEKSANDERA. – Akademicheskij vestnik UralNIIproekt RAASN, Vypusk # 1 / 2011, s. 47-53, http://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/arhitektura-vne-vremeni-ideya-shablonov-proektirovaniya-k-aleksandera(obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.) i Rappaport A.G. K ponimaniju arhitekturnoj formy. – M.: 2000, Dissertacija na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni doktora iskusstvovedenija, predstavlennaja v forme nauchnogo doklada, http://www.archi.ru/lib/publication.html?id=1850569398 (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

Kristofer Aleksander «Jazyk shablonov. Goroda. Zdanija. Stroitel'stvo» -- M.: Izd-vo Studija Artemija Lebedeva, 2014 g., 1096 s., http://www.artlebedev.ru/izdal/yazyk-shablonov/(obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

L. Chernjak. Kiberfizicheskie sistemy na starte. -- «Otkrytye sistemy», # 02, 2014, http://www.osp.ru/os/2014/02/13040038/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.)

Framework for Cyber-Physical Systems. Release 0.8. DRAFT -- Cyber Physical Systems Public Working Group, September 2015. -- http://cpspwg.org/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Stat'ja «rukovodstvo» (governance) v vikipedii: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governance (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Smart City governance na sajte kompanii Fottester: http://blogs.forrester.com/category/smart_city_governance (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Koncepcija regional'noj informatizacii do 2010 goda. Odobrena rasporjazheniem Pravitel'stva Rossijskoj Federacii ot 17 ijulja 2006 g. # 1024-r, http://www.inforegion.ru/ru/main/goverment/reg_inform_concept/reg_inform_concept_text/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

«Novaja arhitektura dlja umnogo goroda» ot 26 sentjabrja 2012 goda na sajte «Gorodskoj tehnolog» http://theurbantechnologist.com/2012/09/26/the-new-architecture-of-smart-cities/?blogsub=confirming#subscribe-blog (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Boyd Cohen. METHODOLOGY FOR 2014 SMART CITIES BENCHMARKING. -- November 20, 2014, https://www.fastcoexist.com/3038818/the-smartest-cities-in-the-world-2015-methodology (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Boyd Cohen. The 3 Generations Of Smart Cities: Inside the development of the technology driven city. -- August 10, 2015, https://www.fastcoexist.com/3047795/the-3-generations-of-smart-cities (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Stat'ja «Sosedskij dozor» [narodnaja druzhina] v vikipedii: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_watch (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Post «Ocharovatel'noe serdce umnogo goroda: granica innovacij» ot 13 avgusta 2012 goda na sajte «Gorodskoj tehnolog» https://theurbantechnologist.com/2012/08/13/the-amazing-heart-of-a-smarter-city-the-innovation-boundary/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Max Nathan, Emma Vandore, Rob Whitehead. A TALE OF TECH CITY: THE FUTURE OF INNER EAST LONDON'S DIGITAL ECONOMY. -- Centre for London 2012, 70 p., https://www.demos.co.uk/files/A_Tale_of_Tech_City_web.pdf?1340965124 (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Sajt organizacii Tehnicheskie goroda Velikobritanii, nacelennoj na vzrashhivanie cifrovoj jekonomiki v Londone i Velikobritanii: http://www.techcityuk.com/(obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Results of 3rd Advanced Architecture Contest, |Tuesday, Jan 19, 2010, http://bustler.net/news/1331/results-of-3rd-advanced-architecture-contest-the-self-sufficient-city (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Sajt Rika Robinsona: https://theurbantechnologist.com/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

http://www.amey.co.uk/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

«Pjat' shagov k bolee umnom gorodu i filosofskij imperativ sdelat' ih», 11 sentjabrja 2012 g.: http://theurbantechnologist.com/2012/09/11/five-steps-to-a-smarter-city-and-the-philosophical-imperative-for-taking-them/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

«Sem' shagov k bolee umnomu gorodu i imperativ predprinjat' ih», 8 sentjabrja 2013 g.: https://theurbantechnologist.com/seven-steps-to-a-smarter-city/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Actionable Business Architecture for Smarter Cities: Enabling better services, greater prosperity and higher productivity. -- IBM Global Business Services, 2011, http://www.itworldcanada.com/archive/Documents/whitepaper/ITW218A_Actionable_Business.pdf (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

“Business Strategy: IDC Government Insights' Smart City Maturity Model — Assessment and Action on the Path to Maturity” – IDC (Document # GI240620), April 2013, 25 p., http://az370354.vo.msecnd.net/publicsector/citynext/whitepapers/IDC%20Government%20Insights'%20Smart%20City%20Maturity%20Model_IDC.pdf (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

IDC MaturityScape: Smart City 2.0. – IDC, Dec 2015 (Doc # US40814315), 15 p., http://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=US40814315 (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

JEFFREY PEEL. Internet Of Things And Citizen Engagement. MAY 4, 2015, https://citizen20series.com/internet-of-things-and-citizen-engagement/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Kuznecov M. I. Primenenie agile pri razrabotke proekta dlja gosudarstvennogo zakazchika. 22 aprelja 2015, https://habrahabr.ru/post/289900/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Cikl zrelosti tehnologii (Hype cycle) Gartner — pri vnedrenii novoj sistemy na predprijatii. 22 oktjabrja 2013, https://habrahabr.ru/post/198506/ (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Neville Cannon. Hype Cycle for Digital Government Technology 2016. -- Gartner, 11 July 2016, https://www.gartner.com/doc/3372417/hype-cycle-digital-government-technology. (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Andrea Di Maio. The E-Government Hype Cycle Meets Web 2.0. – Gartner Industry Research, 2 October 2007, http://wiki.dbast.com/images/b/b3/The_E-Government_Hype_Cycle_Meets_Web_2-0.pdf (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Alfonso Velosa and Bettina Tratz-Ryan. Hype Cycle for Smart City Technologies and Solutions, 2012. – Gartner, 30 July 2012, https://www.gartner.com/doc/2098315/hype-cycle-smart-city-technologies (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Linda Tucci. Gartner: It's time for IT and OT to merge. – TechTarget, 9 April 2008, http://searchcio.techtarget.com/news/1308982/Gartner-Its-time-for-IT-and-OT-to-merge

Nagayoshi Nakano, Bettina Tratz-Ryan, Andrew H Kim. Hype Cycle for Smart City Technologies and Solutions, 2016. – Gartner, 15 July 2016, https://www.gartner.com/doc/3371753/hype-cycle-smart-city-technologies (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Rick Howard and Andrea Di Maio. Hype Cycle for Smart Government, 2013. – Gartner, 22 July 2013, https://www.gartner.com/doc/2555215/hype-cycle-smart-government- (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Andrea Di Maio, Rick Howard, Glenn Archer. Introducing the Gartner Digital Government Maturity Model – Gartner, 22 September 2015, https://www.gartner.com/doc/3135317/introducing-gartner-digital-government-maturity (obrashhenie 12 fevralja 2017 g.).

Simon Mingay, Stephen Stokes. Hype Cycle for Sustainability and Green IT, 2012. – Gartner, 31 July 2012, https://www.gartner.com/doc/2099915/hype-cycle-sustainability-green-it (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Vishal Tripath, Anshul Gupta. Hype Cycle for Sustainability, 2016. – Gartner, 20 July 2016, https://www.gartner.com/doc/3385317/hype-cycle-sustainability- (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Vishal Tripathi, Anshul Gupta. Hype Cycle for Green IT, 2015/ -- Gartner, 28 July 2015, https://www.gartner.com/doc/3101522/hype-cycle-green-it- (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Introduction to the PlanIT Urban Operating System™ Architecture. -- LIVING PLANIT, June 2016, Version 18, http://www.living-planit.com/pdf/living-planit-introduction-to-uos-architecture-whitepaper.pdf (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Guest Blogger. RANKING QUESTIONS VS. RATING QUESTIONS. May 11, 2011, http://blog.verint.com/ranking-questions-vs-rating-questions (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Giffinger, R., Kramar, H., & Haindl, G. (2008). The role of rankings in growing city competition. – In: Proceedings of the 11th European Urban Research Association (EURA) Conference, Milan, Italy, October 9-11. Istochnik: http://publik.tuwien.ac.at/files/PubDat_167218.pdf. (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

2thinknow – Global Innovation Agency. Innovation Cities™ Program. Making Cities Innovative. http://www.innovation-cities.com/ (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Mercer -- WESTERN EUROPEAN CITIES TOP QUALITY OF LIVING RANKING. https://www.mercer.com/newsroom/western-european-cities-top-quality-of-living-ranking-mercer.html# (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

The Green City Index. A summary of the Green City Index research series. A research project conducted by the Economist Intelligence Unit sponsored by Siemens. 2012. https://www.siemens.com/entry/cc/features/greencityindex_international/all/en/pdf/gci_report_summary.pdf (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Digital Cities Survey 2016 [in the U.S.], http://www.govtech.com/dc/digital-cities/ (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Rafael Achaerandio, Roberta Bigliani, José Curto, Gaia Gallotti. White paper: Smart Cities Analysis in Spain 2012 — The Smart Journey, -- IDC, September 2012, https://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prAP41181416 (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Marc Holzer and Aroon P. Manoharan. Digital Governance in Municipalities Worldwide (2015-16). -- The E-Governance Institute, National Center for Public Performance School of Public Affairs and Administration, Rutgers University-Newark , 2016, https://spaa.newark.rutgers.edu/sites/default/files/files/EGov/Publications/Digital%20Governance%20in%20Municipalities%20Worldwide%20(2015-16).pdf (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

European smart cyties ranking, http://www.smart-cities.eu/ranking.html (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Matthew Owen. The Intelligent Community Forum Names the Top7 Intelligent Communities of 2017. -- February 9th, 2017, http://www.intelligentcommunity.org/icf_names_the_top7_intelligent_communities_of_2017 (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

[Fokus gruppa Mezhdunarodnogo Sojuza Jelektrosvjazi po internet veshhej i umnym gorodam i soobshhestvam] SG20: Internet of things (IoT) and smart cities and communities (SC&C), https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/studygroups/2017-2020/20/Pages/default.aspx (obrashhenie 13 fevralja 2017 g.).

Mezhdunarodnyj kongress «SMART RUSSIA 2016» http://www.smartcongress.ru/ Retrieved: Dec, 2016

Namiot D. E., Shneps-Shneppe M. A. Ob otechestvennyh standartah dlja Umnogo Goroda //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 7. – S.32-37

Volkov A. A., Namiot D. E., Shneps-Shneppe M. A. O zadachah sozdanija jeffektivnoj infrastruktury sredy obitanija //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2013. – T. 1. – #. 7. – S.1-10

KPIs on Smart Sustainable Cities http://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/ssc/Pages/KPIs-on-SSC.aspx Retrieved: Dec, 2016

Sformirovan sostav Nabljudatel'nogo Soveta po podgotovke «Rejtinga umnyh gorodov Rossii» http://iri.rf/news/13927/ Retrieved: Dec, 2016

Kuprijanovskij V. P. i dr. Cifrovaja jekonomika i Internet Veshhej–preodolenie silosa dannyh //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 8. – S.36-42.

Kuprijanovskij V. P. i dr. " Razumnaja voda”: Integrirovannoe upravlenie vodnymi resursami na baze smart-tehnologij i modelej dlja umnyh //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 4. – S.20-29.

Kuprijanovskij V. P. i dr. Standarty dlja sozdanija dorozhnyh kart umnyh gorodov na primere BSI //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 8. – S.9-19.

Kuprijanovskij V. P., Namiot D. E., Kuprijanovskij P. V. Standartizacija Umnyh gorodov, Interneta Veshhej i Bol'shih Dannyh. Soobrazhenija po prakticheskomu ispol'zovaniju v Rossii //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 2. – S.34-40.

PD 8101:2014 Smart cities. Guide to the role of the planning and development process http://shop.bsigroup.com/ProductDetail/?pid=000000000030294642 Retrieved: Dec, 2016

PAS 181:2014. Smart city Framework. Guide to

establishing strategies for smart cities and communities http://www.bsigroup.com/en-GB/smart-cities/Smart-Cities-Standards-and-Publication/PAS-181-smart-cities-framework/ Retrieved: Dec, 2016

Kuprijanovskij V. P. i dr. Cifrovaja jekonomika=modeli dannyh+bol'shie dannye+arhitektura+prilozhenija? //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 5. – S. 1-13.

Datta S. K. et al. oneM2M architecture based user centric IoT application development //Future Internet of Things and Cloud (FiCloud), 2015 3rd International Conference on. – IEEE, 2015. – S. 100-107.

Shneps-Shneppe M. A. Kak stroit' umnyj gorod Chast' 2. Organizacija «oneM2M» kak prototip v oblasti standartov umnogo goroda //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 2. – S. 11-17.

Namiot D. E. i dr. Standarty v oblasti bol'shih dannyh //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 11. – S. 12-18.

OneM2M http://onem2m.org Retrieved: Dec, 2016

FIWARE http://fiware.org Retrieved: Dec, 2016

HyperCat http://hypercat.io Retrieved: Dec, 2016

Horizon 2020: Smart Cities and Communities https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/events/horizon-2020-smart-cities-and-communities-information-and-brokerage-event Retrieved: Dec, 2016

Strategicheskie iniciativy umnyh gorodov, vhodjashhih v Sojuz otkrytyh i gibkih umnyh gorodov (Open and Agile Smart Cities, OASC), sm.: http://www.oascities.org/oasc-adds-cities-countries-to-create-global-smart-city-market/

Putin predlozhil zapustit' programmu cifrovoj jekonomiki v RF. http://tass.ru/ekonomika/3830997, 1 dekabrja 2016 g.

V.P. Kuprijanovskij, S.A. Sinjagov. D.P. Namiot. P.M. Bubnov. K.V. Kuprijanovskaja. Novaja pjatiletka BIM - infrastruktura i umnye goroda.// International Journal of Open Information Technologies – 2016 --T. 4. -- # 8. S. 20-35

V.P. Kuprijanovskij. SA. Bulancha. V.V. Kononov. K.Ju. Chernyh, D.E. Namiot, A.P. Dobrynin. Umnye goroda kak «stolicy» cifrovoj jekonomiki//International Journal of Open Information Technologies. –2016. – T. 4. -- # 2. S. 42-52.

Namiot D. E., Zubareva E. V. Goroda, upravljaemye dannymi //International Journal of Open Information Technologies. – 2016. – T. 4. – #. 12. - C. 79-85.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


IT-EDU-2017   Servletsuite

ISSN: 2307-8162